News   Lethality

Stratcom Commander: Failing to Replace Nuclear Triad Akin to Disarmament

Feb. 28, 2020 | BY C. Todd Lopez , DOD News

With both Russia and China making great advances in their strategic weapons arsenals, the U.S. must update its nuclear triad or risk the prospect of existing systems needing to be dismantled due to age — an outcome tantamount to disarmament, a top Navy official said.

''When we talk about the modernization of the triad, what we leave out is the 'or else.' And the other choice that we have is not to keep what we have. The entire triad is reaching the end of its useful life,'' Admiral Charles Richard, commander of United States Strategic Command testified. Richard  appeared yesterday before the House Armed Services Committee's strategic forces subcommittee. ''So, either we replace what we have now, or we start to divest, almost on a path to disarmament, in the face of this growing threat.''

A missile launch leaves burning trail in sky.
Minuteman Launch
An unarmed Minuteman III intercontinental ballistic missile launches during a developmental test at Vandenberg Air Force Base, Calif., Feb. 6, 2019.
Photo By: Air Force Senior Airman Clayton Wear
VIRIN: 190206-F-XJ735-004A

Dr. James H. Anderson, who is currently performing the duties of the deputy undersecretary of defense for policy, reminded lawmakers that the fiscal year 2021 budget request for nuclear forces is $28.9B — roughly 4.1% of the total DOD request. Modernization and recapitalization of those nuclear forces is a mere 1.7% of the total DOD budget request, he said.

''This committee is well aware of the age of the Triad systems and the challenge the department faces in sustaining these systems as we proceed with modernizing U.S. nuclear forces after decades of deferred recapitalization,'' Anderson said. ''Funding these critical requirements ensures that modern replacements will be available before the nation's legacy systems reach the end of their extended-service lives and we lose them altogether.''

A missile interceptor launches amid an ignition cloud.
First Salvo
The lead ground-based Interceptor is launched from Vandenberg Air Force Base, Calif., March 25, 2019, in the first salvo engagement test of a threat-representative intercontinental ballistic missile target. The test’s two interceptors successfully intercepted a target launched from the Ronald Reagan Ballistic Missile Defense Test Site on Kwajalein Atoll in the Pacific Ocean.
Photo By: Lisa Simunaci, Missile Defense Agency
VIRIN: 190325-D-AD122-004A

Recapitalization of the U.S. nuclear triad involves new submarines, such as the Columbia-class ballistic missile submarines; new intercontinental ballistic missiles as part of the Ground-Based Strategic Deterrent program; and new bomber aircraft, such as the B-21 Raider.

Richard told lawmakers he characterizes Russia's efforts as an ''explosion in capability,'' that extends beyond a mere recapitalization of its own triad, and includes nuclear weapons and nuclear-powered weapons that are not strategic and are non-treaty-accountable. Russia is also developing new kinds of delivery systems — including hypersonic glide, nuclear-powered cruise and undersea unmanned nuclear-powered systems.

A missile launches from the ocean amid clouds of smoke.
Trident Missile
An unarmed Trident II D5 missile launches from the ballistic missile submarine USS Nebraska off the coast of California, March 26, 2018. The test launch was part of the U.S. Navy Strategic Systems Program’s demonstration and shakedown operation certification process.
Photo By: Navy Petty Officer 1st Class Ronald Gutridg
VIRIN: 180326-N-UK333-012A

''But it goes beyond that,'' Richard said. ''They have new command and control. They have new warning systems. They have new doctrine. They are exercising [at] a level that we hadn't seen before. They even do civil defense. That is a concept the U.S. abandoned back in the early '60s. This is a very comprehensive approach that Russia is undertaking.''

China, Richard said, is doing much the same thing — but the key difference is that China doesn't talk about it.

''While they are very opaque and they don't speak about it very frequently, they will have all the same capabilities that Russia has, giving them all the same options,'' he said.

The U.S. maintains sea-based, land-based and air-launched nuclear capabilities — collectively referred to a ''nuclear triad.'' The Ground-Based Strategic Deterrent is expected to replace about 400 existing Minuteman III intercontinental ballistic missiles.

A submarine in the water.
190131-N-LW591-002
The nuclear-powered, fast-attack submarine USS North Dakota pulls into its homeport at Naval Submarine Base New London in Groton, Conn., Jan. 31, 2019. The sub was returning from the U.S. European Command area of responsibility.
Photo By: Navy Cmdr. Jason M. Geddes
VIRIN: 190131-N-LW591-002A

Richard said eliminating one leg of the triad — for instance, forgoing ground-based missiles to create a two-pronged nuclear response — changes the calculus for executing U.S. strategic deterrence.

''We went through a nuclear posture review and determined that we needed tailored strategies for each of our adversaries,'' Richard said. ''The triad is what gives me the capabilities; it's the inherent flexibility in the triad that enables me to execute those strategies. If we don’t modernize, I don’t have those capabilities.''