ESSAY WINNER Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates presents U.S. Air Force Col. Paul Judge with a certificate, July 2, 2007, at the Pentagon, for winning the 2007 Secretary of Defense Transformation Essay Competition. He wrote about the concept of Capabilities-Based Planning, while a student at the Air War College. SHARE: Download: Full Size (0.03 MB) Credit: VIRIN: 542708-S-HOE50-386.jpg Photo Gallery